I'm finding OKCupid to be frustrating. There are lots of great people in my area. I'm fairly sure I'd get on well with three of the four people I've started conversations with. Trouble is I find writing messages back and forth or using IMs is so dull and time consuming.
I never IM with people. My chat function is always turned off at OKC. I prefer the messages because I can respond in my own time, when I feel like it.
. . . because I don't know how to flirt without direct conversation and body language, I end up posting walls of text at people. I'm sure some of them must think I'm crazy by now.
I'm shit at this.
It doesn't have to be flirty to grab a woman's attention. In fact, I think it's better if it is more conversational than flirty. Focus on one thing in a person's profile, something way down at the bottom of the page so they know you actually read the whole damn thing. I really appreciate someone scrolling all the way down to read my very carefully composed profile, which I admit is way too long. Anyway, then just write one paragraph of no more than four or five sentences, saying why that particular item moved you to write. You don't have to be witty or clever, although that is awesome, but you should be upbeat in some way. You can be humble but not too self-deprecating. And close with something like "would be nice to continue the conversation."
As an example, I have something in my profile in the "secrets you wouldn't tell anyone," or whatever that section is called, where I write about not winning a statewide spelling bee when I was in the 8th grade. I say, "Don't ask what word I lost on. It still stings." Well, lots of men will contact me to guess what word it was, or to relay their own spelling bee stories, and a lot of those messages are very clever. And it's nice that they are not writing about my looks, hooking up, or the love and romance part of my profile, because it shows me they see themselves as more well-rounded than that, and that they have more to offer. I would say that, 9 times out of 10, the messages which prompt me to reply are not flirtatious
at all.
I usually check out their profiles if their picture seems attractive, current, and real (you'd be surprised how many men who are clearly in their 60s or 70s, list their age as 49) . If a guy writes too much, it does come off as a little crazy or like a cut-and-paste. If he doesn't write enough, I usually just delete and block. If the little picture doesn't show enough of what he looks like, I won't always bother visiting his profile -- unless I like what he wrote and his message to me is really great, thoughtful, or makes me laugh out loud.