Wow, Magdlyn, I'm sorry to hear about your trouble. That all sounds REALLY awful!
Thanks! It's taking me a while to recover. Didn't help that I ended up dating another one this past winter/early spring. This time I recognized the signs and got out early.
Thankfully, I am certain that my boyfriend is not a psychopath. He's actually really gentle and squishy and compassionate for the most part,
OK, I believe you and all, but my ex
seemed quite squishy and gentle, nature loving, a feminist, and all that... for the first year. Sociopaths are excellent at hooking compassionate women and "mirroring" their normal emotions, until they hook you-- and then their true agenda and lack of actual personality comes out.
and if anything, up until really recently, he had trouble saying no to people or asking for what he wanted. He can be kind of dense and oblivious and easily distracted in a moment, though. He seems to have learned a lot since he first started being interested in this new woman (November-ish), when we went through those troubles, and he has made it clear to me that he will make concessions to try to make me comfortable. Despite the inconvenience to me, I was actually kind of proud of him that he stood up to me to continue doing what he wanted, instead of feeling pressured by me and caving and then feeling like I was keeping him from it.
Well, that sounds good, but...
If anything, I worry a teensy bit about HER being the flaunt-y one, because she self-admittedly (to me, in a private conversation) has a history of being manipulative to guys, insecure, and lonely, plus she's really smart and is a sadist. The combination of those factors has me on my tiptoes,
Yeah... I've been involved in BDSM for 6 years now, and I think SO many Dom types have severe issues, and can only dominate in a relationship because they are limited and don't have fully mature compassionate, open, loving personalities. It's very frustrating, because I like to play the sub sometimes (I am a switch), but time after time, Doms fail me after one date or a few dates because they turn out to just be... losers!
They turn out to be insecure, have low self esteem, are depressed/suicidal, come from bad childhoods, need therapy but won't get it, are bad communicators, maybe have a revulsion to body fluids (won't kiss or do oral), etc etc. Sometimes they get lost in Top space and go too far with the impact or bondage play... ugh. Sometimes they seem to feel a discussion about the sub's limits reduces their power as the Top.

Sometimes the sub can end up feeling like a sex toy, not a full person, to their Dom. Sometimes they suck at aftercare, or aren't even aware it's required.
Some will come right out and admit they like torturing subs who themselves have low self esteem or outright self-hatred. It's a game filled with landmines, and I am sure many with experience in BDSM will agree.
because my boyfriend's ex used to manipulate the hell out of him, and it's low-hanging fruit because he can indeed be pretty malleable. I've chosen to take the high road and teach him to shore up those weaknesses, rather than exploiting them, but it has been tempting once or twice.
A good Dom/me will have the well being of their sub/slave in mind, and the D/s play can help the sub grow, mature, become more assertive, brave, fearless, successful and happy in their vanilla life. But these kinds of D types are so few and far between, ime.
Of course, a healthy D/s dynamic can also help the Dom to grow and become a mature actualized person as well. Nobody is perfect, and Doms are flawed human beings just like their sub, even though they are the ones nominally in charge!
So far, though, she's never been anything but nice to me directly; I'm cautiously optimistic to see how she complies with the new guidelines.
The new guidelines, which he brought to her yesterday, were that they use smaller needles, puncture only on the back or other areas that will not be generally visible to me during sex, ice afterwards, and refrain from messing with the needles while they are in. He said that she told him that messing with the needles while they are in adds to the bruising, and though it is a fun sensation for him, he is willing to forgo that part to make me happier. They came up with that on their own. He did not tell her that it was me who was freaked out by the marks, but rather just told her that he does not like them and does not want to see them on himself (which is also true; while he did tell me he had a flash of pleasant remembering when seeing them, he'd prefer, in general, not to be marked up).
As for me, I tried last night to keep my eyes closed during sex. Ha, that was weird. I didn't realize how much I depend on the visual of him to reach orgasm. I will keep trying it if I need to, and I know that I can have fun having sex even without reaching orgasm; sometimes, it's just about connecting and closeness.
So, it sounds like you're a Domme as well? Almost seems like you two are vying for who is the top dog, instead of collaborating for the benefit of your subby bf. Therefore, the bruises she gives him, instead of being a turn on for you, are a sign of someone else having their way with your toy boy, and it makes you uneasy. Because... you don't trust her to have his well being really in mind for the long term. What do you think?