Yes... More specifically, why I don't want to date partnered guys who talk endlessly about their wives or girlfriends. I really don't care what someone does when they're not with me, as long as I'm getting the amount of contact I need. But when someone expects me to spend a ton of time hearing about their other relationships... It just triggers all those competitive feelings.
I know it's silly, but it feels to me like the guy is purposely framing it as a competition, letting me know the score, the rankings. Like, why would you tell me you did X with so-and-so unless you wanted me to get jealous and competitive??? But then, when I do react that way, and try to get my own chance to do X, I usually get shot down. So it starts to feel like the guy is just telling me all this stuff so I'll know where I stand, know I'm not as important.
Your feelings here are, of course, completely valid, but I'd like to ask a couple of questions and raise a couple of possibilities in the spirit of exploring the issue further.
You say "talk endlessly" and "spend a ton of time"—what, to you, is a ton? I ask this because, for me, when I'm getting to know people on what could ostensibly be a date or is officially a date, sometimes it's impossible for me to tell get-to-know-me stories without either mentioning Rider or being purposefully vague to the point where it feels deceptive.
Like, I know you mentioned before that you don't want to hear a ton about the partner specifically and what she does for work, etc., etc., etc.—basically not "dishing" about their partner like they might with their besties, or trotting characteristics out to prove their partner is "cool with stuff"—that to me seems basic common sense. No one wants to hear a ton about a person they don't know and who is just a connection of someone they are just meeting. It's boring!
But talking about "what [they] did with so-and-so," that, to me, falls in the realm of sharing about
oneself. Most of my adventures have been with partners or friends, and I don't see much difference between sharing tales of these adventures, mentioning they were with Rider (even if only referred to as "my partner"), and sharing similar tales, mentioning they were with platonic BFFs (even if referring to "my bestie").
Maybe if they were wacky, one-off misadventures with bare acquaintances, I'd not bother going into the "who," but most of the time, if I feel like I'm trying to let someone get to know me (and vice versa), I feel like it's normal to tell stories about stuff that's happened and who was there. I expect the same from them. Or if we are already together, I feel like it's normal to keep one another apprised of stuff that's going on in each other's lives.
Like, if I were talking to a hypothetical partner about what I did that weekend, I am the type of person who gives a fair amount of detail in all my stories (ahem, historic post lengths can testify to this), I might say, "XXXX and I went thrifting and—oh, we both found really cool shirts!—and then we went to brunch at ABC and that place had the best biscuit I've had in town, and then we hiked a cool trail in This Park (you should totally go if you haven't been...maybe we can go back together!), and then we were starving so we stopped by the farmer's market and XXXX said they knew how to make this amazing baked apple thingie when we saw how many apples were out, and it really was good! I should get the recipe!"
And, in my mind, it doesn't matter if XXXX is Rider or Oona or Mel or Perry or my cousin or a brand new friend that I'm just starting to get to know. It's just the truth of what happened over my weekend, and they'd asked how my weekend was. It's not a brag of how much cool stuff I did with another person, to rub in the face of the person who asked and make them feel competitive and jealous. If anything, it's telling them cool stuff that I now know about that maybe I can bring into their life to make them do the cool stuff too.
But this part specifically seems like there is something complicated to untangle here...
Like, why would you tell me you did X with so-and-so unless you wanted me to get jealous and competitive??? But then, when I do react that way, and try to get my own chance to do X, I usually get shot down. So it starts to feel like the guy is just telling me all this stuff so I'll know where I stand, know I'm not as important.
If it were me, I would answer "Why would you tell me you did X with so-and-so unless you wanted me to get jealous and competitive?" with "Because I thought we were friends as well as lovers, and friends tell friends stuff that they do."
So I wonder if maybe the reason you get shot down "when [you] do react that way [with jealousy and competition]" to hearing that stuff is some kind of blend of these factors, instead of them telling you you're not important:
1) The person can tell you only want to do X out of a sense of competition and jealousy, and they're not into tit-for-tat, so they become uncomfortable. If a person I was dating, who recently hadn't been very creative in the kitchen, suddenly got a wild hair to cook an elaborate meal directly after I told them someone else had done it, I'd feel a bit odd, like they were trying to create some sort of improved facsimile of my other friend/partner. I'd feel like they were doing it not because they wanted to (out of creativity or to please me), but because they wanted to secure their place in my life as "the one who is the best at everything"...and to me, the effort would be worth less to me if it came from a place of one-upmanship against another person than if it were a sweet gesture inspired by something more genuine. Like "partner + competitiveness = action" < "partner + generosity = same action," if that makes sense.
2) If they've
just done X, maybe they want to wait a while to do it again, and would react more positively if you said, "That sounds cool—I know you just did that and probably don't want to do it again so soon, but I'd love to do that with you sometime!" Like, in one situation from my own life, Rider's ex totally "scooped" me once (coincidentally) by choosing the location (several hours away) for a weekend getaway that I'd been planning on making OUR anniversary getaway a couple of months later. We'd been planning on it but no reservations had yet been made. I was disappointed, and I know he would have gone there again if I'd really had my heart set on it, but I knew it'd be more fun for him if we went somewhere different—and anyway, I really didn't want his recent memories of being there with her to be popping up while he was there with me. While he TOTALLY would have gone there anyway (because that's the kind of subby, accommodating person he is), it would have been COMPLETELY reasonable to me if I'd asked and he'd said no.
I dunno, maybe it's none of that and they are just really being jerks and want you to make sure you know your place and purposefully fostering a spirit of competition. Only you know if you are dating the kind of people who get a rise out of making people compete over them. Some people are indeed like that! I have known a few.