Everything’s still standing [but] things are definitely complicated, just not for the reasons I was anticipating.
“Bree” came up late Friday... We all went out for a late dinner... watched YouTube... drank wine... they cuddled a bit... then we were all off to bed.
You and Amy in your room, Bree in the guest room! And no privacy for either of them up til then! You must have been thinking, wth?
I was up first and made everyone breakfast. Bree [got up, we hung out] for an hour or so... I asked if she wanted to go try and wake Amy up... she just went in to the bedroom and kinda cuddled her awake.
Here’s where things took an odd turn. They had planned to spend Saturday afternoon out on a walking tour of the local college campus... my ‘bowing out’ moment... However, Amy insisted I come with them, and Bree agreed with her... And it was fine, we all had good chemistry...
Or it was all an avoidance tactic on one or both of their parts, and they used your presence as a "beard," so to speak.
...walking around and talking for a few hours. We got back home and quickly showered and changed to go out for the night. [Dinner with friends, dancing, drinks, trivia...]
[But] something was off. [They didn't have sex.]
You came home, watched TV, and then Amy said she was tired and you and she went to bed together, and Bree went to the guest room.
The next day, no sex, and Bree left, and Amy...
wanted to talk...
This is probably going to have to become a whole other thread for advice [on] how best to support Amy through it, but it’ll try to summarize:
Bree is going through a lot; a big move, a potential change in careers, a lack of immediate good friends, still wrestling with unpleasant mental stuff after a bad divorce, body issues, self harm issues, etc.
It’s taking a toll on Bree and the effect it’s having on her personally and her relationship with Amy [who says Bree] has, over the past two or three months become increasingly clingy, moody, sensitive, critical of Amy (accusing her of being too distant, too nosy, too passive, too self absorbed, etc), dismissive of Amy's schoolwork and career goals... [seeming] increasingly frustrated with her role as Amy's “secondary” partner.
She has apparently been suggesting things like Amy moving in with her, [but] Amy is two semesters deep in grad school and eyeballing a doctorate. Bree has regularly not-super-subtly suggested that she and Amy just ignore the boundaries we’ve all agreed upon. [Ie:] condoms [!] we agreed early on that they’d use them for intercourse. Bree has lately really been pushing Amy to just ignore that particular rule.[!]
All this has drained Amy of any emotional energy to invest in Bree.
Amy... is certain that Bree is struggling with severe depression... Amy told me she has been trying for months now to convince Bree to seek self help in the form of therapy, support groups, or anything really, only for Bree to insist that she is fine and that there is nothing wrong [and attacks] Amy for these suggestions... tension has been racking up... Amy is simply unhappy and stressed out in Bree’s company.
She’s miserable because she doesn’t know what to do... it’s gotten to a point where she’s paralyzed trying to even answer a text from Bree... She doesn’t think she can keep the relationship going with her... So, yeah, probably going to be making another thread asking for input on this new situation.
I wondered if Bree was upset that you two got engaged. Not only are you engaged, you two are very entangled. And Amy is using you as her only sounding board about Bree? (You know an awful lot of extremely personal details.) You have no friends to confide in either, except us here.
So, you two aren't really independent enough to do poly properly. Amy is being a leaky hinge. Bree didn't tell you she was self-harming, I don't think. I'm not sure she'd be fine with you knowing something so personal.
Also, we suggested the name Amy for "my girlfriend, my fiancee", but I edited your post a dozen or more times because you called her "my girlfriend" in every sentence referring to her. It's subtle, but this smacks of ownership, entanglement, and possessiveness, as does your slip up in saying you needed to be in "constant contact" with Amy while she was on her proposed Bree dates.
It sounds like Bree has too many problems to be dating right now also. If she's still recovering from bad feelings around her divorce, she's using Amy as a band-aid, to boost her esteem as she's on the rebound.
Also, self harm and not seeking help is some serious shit. Most of us don't like to date a person who has untreated mental issues.
Also, you mentioned condoms, which makes me think Bree is a transwoman (?). So she's dealing with post divorce issues as well as gender transition issues, perhaps.
And finally, the relationship is long distance now. Those are hard to deal with, even when everyone is stable. You're not stable, Bree isn't stable, Amy is neck deep in post-grad work.
All I can say is, from my end it looks like it's time for Amy to let Bree go. Bree can get some help, or not, as she sees fit. Amy shouldn't be acting as her white knight, therapist or life raft.