I'm going to leave it by saying I think you're being very subjective here. If you break down the things that has happened, the ONLY thing PunkRock is responsible for is the dependency issues and how that has affected trust between you. In terms of the other things, you're asking him to date your way because these other things happened to you and the people you (both) love. That's a big ask. People make these allowances for their partners all the time. I've said yes to similar big asks but each time I have said yes and honored that yes for as long as it was needed was when the person acknowledged the enormity and individuality of their request.
Dating my way = letting me know on the calendar when he’s got plans. That’s literally the only “rule” I have so far. I don’t feel that’s a big ask - especially since it is a shared calendar between myself, both him and DarkKnight, and my two daughters who need to know when and who they can contact when there are things going on. Consistency and truthful behavior I don’t consider a rule for dating - it’s a rule for being in my life, period.
The way my marriages work is that we love and support one another. In no place did I ever say that PunkRock was responsible for any of the issues I listed. Honestly, I 100% believe addiction is a disease so in part, I don’t even hold him to blame for the drinking. However, they are very real things that happened last year, continued to happen and are still affecting both me and everyone in the polycule. For anyone to think I would just get over any of these - with my already pre-existing attachment issues - is not being realistic. It would be both cold and callous for either of my partners to be like, “oh well, sucks to be you” and go and do their own thing without taking all these things into account. PunkRock isn’t responsible in healing my trauma, but if he wasn’t willing to support me and understand where my issues are stemming from - he wouldn’t be my husband. He married me knowing my issues needed work, and he saw me overcome them and heal. However, now my life went to complete shit and I’m battling both anxiety, depression and a recent death of a friend, and according to you I need to keep sweet and be happy he’s making “allowances” by putting things on a calendar? No. Relationship anarchy doesn’t work for me. If my guys don’t care about me as a partner or even as a human being, they can leave anytime. It may be a big ask for others to be truthful and open and honest, but those sorts of people would seriously damage me further and I have to protect myself from that.
I say this because I'm sure you're aware that what you count as a "good" hinge likely differs from other people or even most people.
Sure. Definitions are subjective. Maybe others don’t want to know that they can rely on their partners. That’s them, not me. I know what I need and if I don’t get it, then my marriage is going to fail big time. That said, I don’t think that truthfulness and communication and staying clean is something that would differ from what most people would want in a hinge or partner. Regardless, it’s what I need. I don’t really care about what “most people” want.
You need each other in your lives equally so to me, there is just as much pressure on you to compromise with what he might need from his polycule for it to contribute to his good wellbeing as what you need from yours. From my experience, even in the face of broken trust, saying it has to be this way or no way erodes any chance of sustaining the relationship.
So far, I have told him that I remain completely flexible. He’s been up front with the fact that they have yet to define their relationship, and the amount of time that may take from our existing family. I’m sure he has time available, so that shouldn’t be an issue, as long as things are on the calendar so we can plan around everything.
I am trying very hard to accept the addiction issues, every time they come to the front again. To pretend that nothing else exists as barriers to a healthy relationship - but the addiction - with him would be foolish for both of us. It’s the reason I haven’t been dating. I’m doing what I can to try and rebuild myself and keep our family intact.
To just pull out one of them - our daughter was doing heroin and refusing to answer our calls and texts for a year. More than likely prostituting herself to survive. To say that this isn’t an issue that PunkRock is responsible for is true. But it affected him very much as well - he gained 50 pounds and started drinking in secret! If I can’t count on him when she is living in our house, rebuilding her life and we are both struggling with the after effects on our relationship and on us as individuals - no. That’s not a husband. That’s not even a partner. In my family, we lean on each other, with compassion and kindness. Our daughter needs that. But we also need each other to heal. To do it alone and pretend that it is someone else’s problem...nah. I limited my dating because I was and still am in a dark hole. He’s dealing with it differently and that’s okay. But I’m not okay with him forgetting that this trauma exists and is ongoing. Is that too much of an ask? Well, maybe it would be for you. Maybe it would be for most people. Maybe it will be for PunkRock. I hope not in his case.