You feel what you feel.
If this is where you are at?
There has to be a level of attraction (for me to be willing) to have physical play.
That's a fair boundary for you to have. YOU are in charge of your body and who you share it with and when.
Maybe this experience means you do the coffee date BEFORE the casual group sex date. Gives you a chance to sort out attraction/compatibility out ahead of time. Not sign up for group sex sight unseen and then show up only to be turned off by their looks.
thought #2 I am so grossed out that he plays/played with these people. I don't even want him touching me anymore.
If the thought of him playing with people you do not find attractive dims his appeal to you? It is what it is. You could give yourself time to digest that thought.
So I got the idea that that was his level, his attraction type so to speak. It was mine too. Walking in to find not just one or two, but the whole room were folks outside... and I mean really outside... that circle of assumption was shocking. It distorted my view of him.
You had
assumed his "bandwith" of attraction was the same as yours.
I don't think it
distorted your view of him. I think this experience CLARIFIED your view of him. That he's got a different bandwidth of "attractiveness" than you do. While some of his bandwidth overlaps yours? Some of it includes people you would not include in your bandwidth.
So? You are each allowed to develop your own preferences. Some people will dig redheads. Some won't. Some people will dig blonds. Some won't. Some people will dig brunettes. Some won't.
How can I be attractive if they're attractive and vice versa?
Attractive to
who?
- To BF? He seems to be attracted to them and you both.
- To you? You think you are only as lovely as his other partners?
Could you be willing to clarify what you mean? Do you mean you base your own attractiveness by who else he picks for lovers? And if he's picking out people you think are ugly, you start to think you are ugly too?
I hate that I'm feeling this way. I want to keep him but every thought I have of him now is linked to these other people and the negatives I feel.
Well, you could give it some time and find ways to come to terms with it.
Like not attending these play parties with him.
Just attend the groups you do like being in. And change your practices -- like do a coffee date first before signing up.
Changing some of your sex practices with him. For example, if you are fluid bonded, maybe you prefer to bring condoms back?
If this is challenging some core beliefs you have about your own attractiveness, you could examine them to see if these core beliefs still serve you well or if they need updating.
Or you could choose to not date him anymore.
It's your call.
Galagirl