New to Poly- Dating a Married Woman seeking advice

Thanks for this, that's a good question. My idea of hierarchy might be different than theirs. I'm thinking it's more of a priority thing, but I shouldn't assume they feel the same way.

Sounds like you aren't a huge fan of hierarchy situations?

I think it's a moot term. Either what someone's offering you works for you or doesn't. However using the term often means that there are things they know won't work for some people.

Generally I'm at a place now where someone's insistence that they either do OR don't have hierarchy garners more discussion about what exactly that means to them and why they think it's (ir)relevant to their relationship.
 
I think it's a moot term. Either what someone's offering you works for you or doesn't. However using the term often means that there are things they know won't work for some people.

Generally I'm at a place now where someone's insistence that they either do OR don't have hierarchy garners more discussion about what exactly that means to them and why they think it's (ir)relevant to their relationship.
I'm definitely going to ask for clarity on this from them. Best not to assume my ideas align without asking.
 
Magdlyn,

Thank you for all of this, it's incredibly helpful!
Very good perspective on how I spend my time. I most definitely would not want to use the time I have with Annie, to focus on Adam. That time is finite, and I'd definitely prefer to use every second of it with her.

Really appreciate the perspective on "permission" in poly relationships. It makes a lot of sense now that I think it more deeply. Thanks for that.

Yeah, right now my time with her isn't locked into any type of schedule. Her time has been open to me when either Adam is out of town for work, and after they discuss it. Or when he is out with someone else. Overnights are something they are still working through comfort levels with I think. There has been 1, and the next is about a month away. This week it looks like it's 2 dates, the second being dinner with the three of us, and then Annie and I hanging out for a few hours afterwards. Not sure what next week will look like at this point.

Your last question is a really good one. I've been thinking about that, and will see if anything else comes up for me. My initial thoughts were that it would make things easier on all of us, especially Annie, if there was some form of friendship between us. I still think that's probably best, but I guess just knowing him was my initial desire. But, what do I want out of it is a better approach. Definitely I want to understand his feelings, needs, etc around their hierarchy, I think that will be informative. Outside of that I'd like to knoee his preferred relationship dynamics, and if he had a crystal ball what his ideal idea of all of this is months and years down the road. At least from what he can imagine now. Obviously I care much more about what Annie's desires are, but knowing I think is helpful. Time, that's definitely one I want to discuss, I just have to figure out how without trying to go to far to fast I think.
I'll take a positive experience for the three of us above all else.
 
Magdlyn,

Thank you for all of this, it's incredibly helpful!
Very good perspective on how I spend my time. I most definitely would not want to use the time I have with Annie to focus on Adam. That time is finite, and I'd definitely prefer to use every second of it with her.

Really appreciate the perspective on "permission" in poly relationships. It makes a lot of sense now that I think it more deeply. Thanks for that.
The point is that your authority figures give you permission. As a kid, that would be your parents, teachers, etc. But as an adult, a poly adult, if you have partners, you negotiate the kind of arrangements you want, and then you both sign on, so to speak, for this kind of contract.

If she thinks she needs Adam's "permission," she can blame him for what she can or can't do. But it ends up sounding like, "My dad says I have to be home by 10," kind of deal. It's best if she says (and thinks), "I have to be home by 10," because she herself has agreed to that for her own reasons. It's not good to make your OSO the bad guy.
Yeah, right now my time with her isn't locked into any type of schedule. Her time has been open to me when either Adam is out of town for work, and after they discuss it. Or when he is out with someone else.
This is kind of a flag... in poly, you can't always arrange to have a date with your OSO while your partner is on their date with their OSO (or out of town, or out with friends, etc.) What if he has plans, so you and Annie "get to" have a date, but then his plans are cancelled? Would Annie "have to" cancel her date with you just to keep him company? That ends up being like a mini veto.
Your last question is a really good one. I've been thinking about that, and will see if anything else comes up for me. My initial thoughts were that it would make things easier on all of us, especially Annie, if there was some form of friendship between us.
Valid. My nesting partner wishes her bf was more open to spending time with me, as a KTP V. But his time is limited and he is rather introverted, so our dinners together are fairly rare. My bf would also like to spend more time with my gf... But in the past, some of my former bfs have ended up getting crushes on my gf, and it gets weird. We tried some sexual threesomes quite some time ago, but it didn't work out (to say the least). So we avoid too much togetherness to this day.

I still think that's probably best, but I guess just knowing him was my initial desire. But, "What do I want out of it?" is a better approach. Definitely, I want to understand his feelings, needs, etc., around their hierarchy, I think that will be informative. Outside of that, I'd like to know his preferred relationship dynamics, and if he had a crystal ball what his ideal idea of all of this is months and years down the road, at least from what he can imagine now.
Generally, I get that kind of info about my meta from my actual partner. I don't want to be too nosy with my metas and all up in their business. I'm not dating them.
Obviously, I care much more about what Annie's desires are, but knowing is helpful, I think.
I just leave that kind of negotiation to my partner and meta. Then my partner can come to me with the final result, or the evolving decisions she has made or needs she would like me to meet. She has to accommodate her other partner. I just accommodate her.
Time, that's definitely one I want to discuss, I just have to figure out how, without trying to go too far too fast. I'll take a positive experience for the three of us above all else.
I know other poly people might disagree, but I've never been a fan of "helping" my partner to negotiate their issues with their other partner. I am not their marriage counselor. I don't want to be in between them like that.
 
Hey Magdlyn,

Thanks yet again for all of this!

I definitely lean towards letting the two of them work out details on their own as well. I would not want to negotiate for Annie, and especially not without her directly asking me first. I think I would frame the question about time to the two of them. Perhaps something like "I'm curious of the two of you have had discussions about how you see yourselves spending time with your OSO's, and if you don't mind me asking what did those discussions look like?" - Or perhaps I won't ask at all and just asking Annie later when we sre alone. But no, I agree after 10 years of therapy and boundary work, I wouldn't feel comfortable being what could be seen as Annie's voice with Adam. I feel it's definitely better for them to grow into this in their own way and time.


Yeah, the coordination of timing with OSO's being centered around Adam traveling or both of them having plans, is a flag Evie and Seasoned mentioned earlier as well. Thank you for validsting that. It does concern me, but I think I'm going to excercise some patients on this and see how they evolve over the coming months. It does seem a bit codependent, but maybe they are just finding their growth edges. I have heard Annie share some conversations that sounds like minor change in that area. I also have confidence that that if plans are made they will be followed through with, even if things were to fall through for Adam.

Meeting up tonight, 🤞
 
The first meeting went well! Lots to chat about, it was easy, short, and sweet. I hear he thinks I'm a good guy, and can see why she likes me.

Also, I brought up exactly zero things about anything poly or related. 😂 I just followed their lead. He honestly seemed a bit nervous, and I was sensing a little tension between the two of them. I did ask him about his OSO toward the end, he really seemed to like that.

Annie and I hungout afterwards, and we talked at length. Glad I didn't bring anything up, sounds like their have been some "growing pains" on Adams part over the last few days. In the four years they've been swinging with couples, and the close to a year now they've had an open marriage. He's fallen in love with a few woman and spoken to Annie about it. She worked through the difficult feelings she had, and hasn't looked back. Apparently the shoe is on the other foot now. This is the first time Annie has had an emotional connection and used the feeling word love about anyone other than Adam. Soo yeah, "growing pains".
Actually quite a few of the things all of you shared with me seem to be occuring in the background. He wants lots of rules, is currently 1000% uncomfortable with dynamics that don't include "permission". Prefers to have us start limiting our time together to one day a week, without an overnight. Kind of shit if I'm being completely honest.

I'm hoping he just had a freak out and will come to his senses, he seems like a very reasonable person, that is capable of of communicating well from what Annie tells me. This weekend they are visiting some friends out of state that are a long time poly married couple. Adam is close with the woman in that marriage, Annie not so much with the husband. My hope is that he opens up, talks with his friend and gets some good advice. Fingers crossed 🤞 anyway.

Thanks again for all the insight everyone. It's been invaluable in helping me navigate this, and communicate with Annie in none monogamous terms through these twists and turns.
 
Last edited:
easy, short, and sweet. I hear he thinks I'm a good guy...
Contradicts with:
He seemed nervous... tension between the two of them...

"growing pains" on Adams part...

He wants lots of rules, is currently 1000% uncomfortable with dynamics that don't include "permission". Prefers to have us start limiting our time together to one day a week, without an overnight. Kind of shit...


I'm hoping he just had a freak out and will come to his senses...
Uh oh. I hope things improve. Baby steps. It's OK if he wants to take it more slowly at first. It seems hypocritical that he's "fallen in love" several times in one year, but now freaking out that she's finally fallen for you. But that's how being new to polyamory often plays out. It's a rollercoaster. He may feel fine one day and absolutely lost the next.
 
Contradicts with:

No it doesn't. Any of Adam's discomfort could exist despite knowing OP is a lovely guy. He was nervous. He has doubts about poly. That doesn't take away from him thinking OP is a good human.

I'm hoping he just had a freak out and will come to his senses,

I'd start to want to see Eve (is that what we're calling her?!) step up and say what she wants/needs and not just passively wait for Adam to say what is acceptable.
 
No it doesn't. Any of Adam's discomfort could exist despite knowing OP is a lovely guy. He was nervous. He has doubts about poly. That doesn't take away from him thinking OP is a good human.
That wasn't my point. It was the easy and sweet part that contradicts with tension and nervousness, imo.
I'd start to want to see Eve...
Annie
step up and say what she wants/needs and not just passively wait for Adam to say what is acceptable.
Yes. She is allowing him to have authority over her, impose his will on her, if she is going along with "needing his permission."
 
Yeah, I can empathize with Adam. Things went from Annie, never having an emotional connection in four years. To oh shit I love this guy, and wsnt to send lots of time with him. So I can empathize, but also some of what I've heard is definitely hypocritical. Good for him, but not good for her, at least at this point. There are definitely some insecurities, and jealousy things for him to work through. From what I've heard, yes, it has been a bit of a rollercoaster. Some days he's really supportive and happy for her. Others, total freak outs.

Annie has tested the waters on topics like permission seeking. And discussed how it makes her feel like property. Sounds like that conversation didn't go that well. I think it resulted in him talking about needing to be in a hierarchy ( strange because it already is) and always needing/wanting priority. To Seasoneds point earlier about what hierarchy means to a person would have been super interesting to kmoe here.

Soooo yeah, when he's in a good place he's very supportive, when he's in a bsd place well... It's bad.

He said s couple pretty crappy things to Annie when she talked about something else she wsnted to change about their lives. But that's more between them, so I won't share. But the language resulted in a pretty nasty ultimatum.
Which still troubles me.
 
I get the impression Annie and Adam are riding some rough waters right now in terms of their relationship with each other, and it isn't just poly that's making them fight. I would suggest you give them some space, so as not to be in the middle of things when this all comes to a head. Do your once-a-week thing with Annie; grit your teeth and go without the overnight for now, share your feelings with Annie but don't try to intervene in her conflicts with Adam. It seems to me that it may all blow up soon.
 
Kdt,

Sadly I think you're right. Appreciate your observations and tend to agree. There is something more there than the open marriage/poly thing happening. That's good advice, after she opened up with me about their Monday conversation/fight, I decided it was best not to bring up overnights or days. Hopefully they are able to work through the root cause of whatever is happening between them. But yeah, definitely just a good listener for her about all that, it's not for me to solve or intervene in.
 
Last edited:
Hi Nash Guy,

Yeah I think you should tread with care when it comes to Annie and Adam, their situation seems to be rather explosive right now. Just being a good listener for Annie is about the best you can do for the moment. Hopefully they will come to a relatively peaceful resolution for their problems, but it might take a while.

Regards,
Kevin T.
 
Hi Nash Guy,

Yeah I think you should tread with care when it comes to Annie and Adam, their situation seems to be rather explosive right now. Just being a good listener for Annie is about the best you can do for the moment. Hopefully they will come to a relatively peaceful resolution for their problems, but it might take a while.

Regards,
Kevin T.
I hope so! Definitely going to be extra careful with my opinions and any advice giving.

I appreciate you!
 
Thanks; I hope I can be of help.
 
Actually, since Annie has feelings for you, I don't think it's a great thing for you to spend a lot of time even listening to her talk about her fights with Adam. You'd be imposing on his privacy. I'd imagine he'd rather you don't see all their dirty laundry. If Annie is having marital issues, she is not a good candidate for poly. She could talk about her troubles with supportive platonic friends or they could seek counseling from an objective observer. You're too invested in this to be a good counselor.

I decided, after a time of dating as a poly woman, that I'd stay away from dating someone from a couple who was just opening up. There is a lot of preparation to be done when you shift from mono to poly. This will be hard to hear, but I'd recommend stepping back entirely for several months, and then have a check-in to see where they are at. No chatting, no checking Annie's socials, just go no contact. When a couple is struggling it's a terrible idea to add another person. I'm speaking from experience.
 
Hey Mags, ( can I call you Mags? )

Very much appreciate the thoughtful approach and experience. Though, I don't 100% agree with everything you wrote, I can understand your point of view. I'll write in more detail why I disagree with some of what you shared a bit later. Busy with work at the moment.
 
Hey Mags, ( can I call you Mags? )

Very much appreciate the thoughtful approach and experience. Though, I don't 100% agree with everything you wrote, I can understand your point of view. I'll write in more detail why I disagree with some of what you shared a bit later. Busy with work at the moment.
Yes, I'd be happy if you called me Mags.
 
Back
Top