Please help

nelly

New member
Hi everyone, I've been lurking for a while but this is my first post. I'm in a situation and really don't have anyone to talk to, so I'm hoping the experienced poly people might be able to share some advice.

I've been with my husband for 5 years, married for one. We've always communicated well, and have a really trusting bond. Before we got married I expressed interest in opening up the relationship. He was hesitant but ultimately said keep him in the loop if any thing came up and we could see where it went. A few months later while on vacation I asked him about it again and his answer hadn't changed. So I was like, awesome! This is going to be great!

Fast forward to a year later I end up developing feelings for a man I see occasionally at work. We hang out, and I tell the guy that I'm interested but need to discuss it with my husband. I talk to my husband and an EPIC meltdown occurs... Tears, he's throwing up, just insanely jealous. This comes as a completed surprise to me, who has been waiting patiently for a decent potential partner to show up. My husband says he was never into it and I should have known that. Long story short, he doesn't want any part of this and this whole situation makes me confront that I don't want just sex outside my marriage but relationships and may actually be poly. After reading "More Than Two", everything (the being in love with two men at 19, the roommate situation where i lived with a man and woman couple and developed feelings for both of them, the serial monogamy) starts to make sense.

Things kept getting worse over the last few weeks. We started arguing about stupid shit and snapping at each other (which we never do). A week ago, I told him I may identify as poly. He didnt seem upset, but there next day he told me he was driving to California to get away for a little while. I asked him if it was because of ther poly thing and he said yes, but promised he would come back. He left and it seemed like things were okay, but he has barely responded to my texts, won't return phone calls and says he's figuring it out.

Im going through a lot of ups and downs. I feel like he won't come back. I'm angry. I just want a chance to figure this out together. I'll admit I'm not the best at talking about my feelings, but how can I even try? And I'll admit this all probably came on a bit quickly, but then again I did give him pretty fair warning that I wanted to explore this side of sexuality.

I sent him a text today saying I respect his space, and will answer his questions honestly. That I love him and care about him. After I got home from work I just laid on the couch and I haven't been able to move. I'm so sad. I was honest, yet I am in so much pain. Do people even really want the truth or do they just say they want the truth?

Is it possible to be poly and be in a monogamous relationship? Does it work out? Should I keep waiting for him to call like a depressed sack of shit? What do I do? All I want is a chance to spread love in the world... Why does it hurt so much?

-Nelly
 
Hi everyone, I've been lurking for a while but this is my first post. I'm in a situation and really don't have anyone to talk to, so I'm hoping the experienced poly people might be able to share some advice.

I've been with my husband for 5 years, married for one. We've always communicated well, and have a really trusting bond. Before we got married I expressed interest in opening up the relationship. He was hesitant but ultimately said keep him in the loop if any thing came up and we could see where it went. A few months later while on vacation I asked him about it again and his answer hadn't changed. So I was like, awesome! This is going to be great!

Fast forward to a year later I end up developing feelings for a man I see occasionally at work. We hang out, and I tell the guy that I'm interested but need to discuss it with my husband. I talk to my husband and an EPIC meltdown occurs... Tears, he's throwing up, just insanely jealous. This comes as a completed surprise to me, who has been waiting patiently for a decent potential partner to show up. My husband says he was never into it and I should have known that. Long story short, he doesn't want any part of this and this whole situation makes me confront that I don't want just sex outside my marriage but relationships and may actually be poly. After reading "More Than Two", everything (the being in love with two men at 19, the roommate situation where i lived with a man and woman couple and developed feelings for both of them, the serial monogamy) starts to make sense.

Things kept getting worse over the last few weeks. We started arguing about stupid shit and snapping at each other (which we never do). A week ago, I told him I may identify as poly. He didnt seem upset, but there next day he told me he was driving to California to get away for a little while. I asked him if it was because of ther poly thing and he said yes, but promised he would come back. He left and it seemed like things were okay, but he has barely responded to my texts, won't return phone calls and says he's figuring it out.

Im going through a lot of ups and downs. I feel like he won't come back. I'm angry. I just want a chance to figure this out together. I'll admit I'm not the best at talking about my feelings, but how can I even try? And I'll admit this all probably came on a bit quickly, but then again I did give him pretty fair warning that I wanted to explore this side of sexuality.

I sent him a text today saying I respect his space, and will answer his questions honestly. That I love him and care about him. After I got home from work I just laid on the couch and I haven't been able to move. I'm so sad. I was honest, yet I am in so much pain. Do people even really want the truth or do they just say they want the truth?

Is it possible to be poly and be in a monogamous relationship? Does it work out? Should I keep waiting for him to call like a depressed sack of shit? What do I do? All I want is a chance to spread love in the world... Why does it hurt so much?

-Nelly

Is it possible to be poly and be in a monogamous relationship?

It is possible, I did it for three years, actually I did it for longer because my husband didn't agree with poly and was raised in a religious home that frowned on that type of relationship. Was I happy, no. Did it finally work itself out, yes but it took a lot of hard work, honesty, at times brutal honesty and in the end I had to face which was more important to me, him or living a poly lifestyle.

I chose him.

Does it work out?

Sometimes but not always. Our experience was that he slowly came around to the idea and we formed a closed v, he was the hinge on which we were grouped. When that relationship broke up there were hurt feelings that were all over the place and I know that part of him blames me for that hurt. Had he not gotten into the poly world because I wanted that he would not have experienced that hurt.

What do I do?

No one can tell you that. If I were you, and at one point I was in the same situation, I would take a good hard look at what I wanted, what I was willing to lose to get it and what the gain would be.

All I want is a chance to spread love in the world

For me personally I am not in poly relationships to spread the love but rather because the idea of one love seems so odd to me. While I do struggle with jealousy at times I've always believed that who I love, when I love them and how I love them should not be hampered by what anyone but me thinks. If I'm ok with having two husbands then it's no one else's business!

Why does it hurt so much

Change is difficult and at times painful. It sounds like you love your husband and the thought of losing him is painful to you but I'm not hearing that you are willing to give up the idea of a poly relationship to stay with him either. If that is the case then saying goodbye to someone that you love and care about is always painful.
 
Last edited:
I am sorry you hurt.

I think it hurts because you are coming to terms that your husband doesn't love all of you, as you are, through whatever growth may happen.

He loves his static picture of you.

It also hurts because you went into the marriage with good faith. Where it appears he did not.

He is not owning that you gave him several heads up on this topic. He chose to avoid processing it and went ahead and married. Maybe hoping it was a phase. And now that it has come, he's being all "You should be able to mind reader me that I don't want that!"

He's off getting his head together. Which is better than him being here snapping at you. So give him the space, get your own self together. See a counselor if it helps.

And prepare to have some serious talks when he gets back. These talks could have been had when you were Engaged -- now you are going to have to catch them up. And if they show that you are not actually compatible in fundamentals, and cannot bridge them? You may have to talk about how to part ways.

I am so sorry. :(

Galagirl
 
Last edited:
Wow, girl, he pulled a bait and switch on you. And now he's in full retreat. I am so sorry.

There are so many threads here about poly people trying to convince their staunchly mono spouses to open the relationship... it hardly ever works.

I had to split from my husband of 30 years back in 2008, since I'd lived monogamously with him all that time, while being poly on the inside. We had a few other issues, but that was one of the major factors. I have not regretted it. I am with a much more appropriate partner and more fulfilled than I have ever been (in my love life and love style) before.

Hang in there. My sympathies!
 
Hi nelly,

Really sorry to hear that your husband has had such a bad reaction to poly. It must hurt right down deep in your gut, knowing he is away from you and that you might lose him.

Prepare yourself to make a hard decision about what you want more in your life: poly or your husband. He may make you choose.

With sympathy,
Kevin T.
 
I recommend giving both him and yourself ample time to talk about this, and open up and speak the truth of your hearts about it. Please don't see it as something you need to "fix" right away. Give yourselves lots of time and space -- loving, kind, warm time and space -- to raise things to the next level. And by "raise things to the next level" I simply mean "be very open and honest about stuff that's difficult to feel and/or talk about."

Know that both of you have wonderful, great things to learn by opening up to a deeper, rounder, fuller way of communicating. And give it lots of time and patience. Don't rush it. It's a journey. Enjoy the journey as much as you can.

Keep your heart wide open and be true to yourself.:)
 
Back
Top