Hello Everyone,
I just found this forum and it seems like a wonderful place, so I just decided to join. Here is my situation: my wife (46f) and I (51m) have been married for over 11 years, and have been together for almost 14 years. It is the second marriage for both of us. I have three older children from my first marriage and my wife and I have a 10-year old daughter together. For the first roughly 10 years of our marriage I thought things were perfect. We were inseparable, best friends who loved to do everything together, had amazing sex, loved to travel, had rewarding careers.
During the pandemic my wife got a new job, her dream job, which she initially started doing remotely. Once they went back into the office she began developing a very close friendship with a co-worker. I discovered a text string between them (yes, I suspected something was up and checked her phone, which I should not have done) and was floored by what I discovered. Nothing sexual, but clearly, in my mind, she was having an emotional affair with this guy.
I confronted her. She disagreed that there was anything over the line about the texts and accused me of being controlling. We got ourselves into therapy to work things out and for about the next 18 or so months we tried to deal with this situation. I initially insisted she pull back from him and treat him as a co-worker and casual friend only, which she agreed to do. But over time. she asked me again and again if she could re-kindle her relationship with him. I refused for a while, then relented when I knew I couldn’t stop it if I wanted to.
All the while, she insisted that although she had strong feelings for him and cared deeply for him, it was nothing compared to what we had together.
She initially called him a very good friend, which evolved into a best friend, which eventually evolved into a relationship that she could not live without. I had a lot of anger and resentment over this, did not handle things well, we fought a ton. But neither of us wanted to give in, so we also fought for each other.
Some time last fall, my wife (who is also doing her own work in therapy) starting talking about the fact that she thought she was polyamorous, and that she might love this guy, but not in the same way she loved me. Then last week she finally came completely clean. She is polyamorous, has always been, but never knew it. She claims she (unknowingly) put this side of herself away when we met because of the strength of our bond together, and likely because she knew I would have a hard time with it.
She is in love with this guy (who is also married, but who also found himself in an open marriage, whether he wanted to be or not). She still claims our marriage will remain her first priority, and that the two of them do not have or want a physical relationship, but that she would like to start spending more time with him, meeting his kids, introducing him to our daughter, etc.
Meanwhile, I do not think I am polyamorous, at least not in the way that she is. I am intrigued by the idea of an open marriage from a physical perspective, and think I could get used to some form of ethical non-monogamy, if we were talking about sex only. But, I don’t find the idea of having a secondary emotional relationship intriguing at all, and find myself very jealous of my wife’s other relationship. I wish we could go back to the days when we were inseparable and did everything together, but I know there is no going back.
We are about to start negotiating boundaries with our therapist this week. I am petrified of what she is going to ask for. I love her more than I could ever love another person, so much so that I understand that I have to love her for who she is, not who I want her to be, and that she cannot be happy in our marriage without being true to herself. And I very much want to try to make things work, because I cannot imagine my life without her.
At the same time, I am scared that I am not going to be able to do this. She’s given me permission to see other people, developing FWBs or even a relationship like hers. I’ve started experimenting with the former. but remain uninterested in the later, and honestly would be happiest going back to being monogamous, even though I know that is not going to happen.
I should note, her friend’s open marriage is emotional only. His wife is not sleeping with her other partner, and he claims (I’ve met him) to not want that with my wife.
I’d love any advice on how to handle the situation. Can this work?
Am I kidding myself that she will never want this relationship to become physical? Over the years, sex has become less and less important to her, which I was okay with, but it would bother me if she were sleeping with someone else while our sex life was less than fulfilling for me.
Am I better off ending things now, and just becoming really good friends and co-parents, and letting her do her thing without enduring the pain that is surely ahead of me as I adjust to this new situation? If I put myself out there, could I possibly develop feelings for another person while remaining in love with my wife, or does that kind of thing just not happen?
Thanks in advance for hearing me out. Sorry for the long post.
I just found this forum and it seems like a wonderful place, so I just decided to join. Here is my situation: my wife (46f) and I (51m) have been married for over 11 years, and have been together for almost 14 years. It is the second marriage for both of us. I have three older children from my first marriage and my wife and I have a 10-year old daughter together. For the first roughly 10 years of our marriage I thought things were perfect. We were inseparable, best friends who loved to do everything together, had amazing sex, loved to travel, had rewarding careers.
During the pandemic my wife got a new job, her dream job, which she initially started doing remotely. Once they went back into the office she began developing a very close friendship with a co-worker. I discovered a text string between them (yes, I suspected something was up and checked her phone, which I should not have done) and was floored by what I discovered. Nothing sexual, but clearly, in my mind, she was having an emotional affair with this guy.
I confronted her. She disagreed that there was anything over the line about the texts and accused me of being controlling. We got ourselves into therapy to work things out and for about the next 18 or so months we tried to deal with this situation. I initially insisted she pull back from him and treat him as a co-worker and casual friend only, which she agreed to do. But over time. she asked me again and again if she could re-kindle her relationship with him. I refused for a while, then relented when I knew I couldn’t stop it if I wanted to.
All the while, she insisted that although she had strong feelings for him and cared deeply for him, it was nothing compared to what we had together.
She initially called him a very good friend, which evolved into a best friend, which eventually evolved into a relationship that she could not live without. I had a lot of anger and resentment over this, did not handle things well, we fought a ton. But neither of us wanted to give in, so we also fought for each other.
Some time last fall, my wife (who is also doing her own work in therapy) starting talking about the fact that she thought she was polyamorous, and that she might love this guy, but not in the same way she loved me. Then last week she finally came completely clean. She is polyamorous, has always been, but never knew it. She claims she (unknowingly) put this side of herself away when we met because of the strength of our bond together, and likely because she knew I would have a hard time with it.
She is in love with this guy (who is also married, but who also found himself in an open marriage, whether he wanted to be or not). She still claims our marriage will remain her first priority, and that the two of them do not have or want a physical relationship, but that she would like to start spending more time with him, meeting his kids, introducing him to our daughter, etc.
Meanwhile, I do not think I am polyamorous, at least not in the way that she is. I am intrigued by the idea of an open marriage from a physical perspective, and think I could get used to some form of ethical non-monogamy, if we were talking about sex only. But, I don’t find the idea of having a secondary emotional relationship intriguing at all, and find myself very jealous of my wife’s other relationship. I wish we could go back to the days when we were inseparable and did everything together, but I know there is no going back.
We are about to start negotiating boundaries with our therapist this week. I am petrified of what she is going to ask for. I love her more than I could ever love another person, so much so that I understand that I have to love her for who she is, not who I want her to be, and that she cannot be happy in our marriage without being true to herself. And I very much want to try to make things work, because I cannot imagine my life without her.
At the same time, I am scared that I am not going to be able to do this. She’s given me permission to see other people, developing FWBs or even a relationship like hers. I’ve started experimenting with the former. but remain uninterested in the later, and honestly would be happiest going back to being monogamous, even though I know that is not going to happen.
I should note, her friend’s open marriage is emotional only. His wife is not sleeping with her other partner, and he claims (I’ve met him) to not want that with my wife.
I’d love any advice on how to handle the situation. Can this work?
Am I kidding myself that she will never want this relationship to become physical? Over the years, sex has become less and less important to her, which I was okay with, but it would bother me if she were sleeping with someone else while our sex life was less than fulfilling for me.
Am I better off ending things now, and just becoming really good friends and co-parents, and letting her do her thing without enduring the pain that is surely ahead of me as I adjust to this new situation? If I put myself out there, could I possibly develop feelings for another person while remaining in love with my wife, or does that kind of thing just not happen?
Thanks in advance for hearing me out. Sorry for the long post.
Last edited by a moderator: