I don't understand why your so-called rational brain is telling you you "should" be happy with the first category when Castle is what really rocks your world.
I have been thinking on this all day... It's like I don't think I *deserve* Castle. Not because there's anything wrong with me, but because I'm not giving him enough in return to warrant how well he treats me.
There is this narrative in my head - what nycindie would call a worm - that says a woman's value to a man is tied to her ability and willingness to build him a home and a family. Men commit not for companionship or sex, but to have ... A mom, basically. Someone who cleans and cooks and takes care of the kids and pets. That's the trade off they get for giving up their freedom to screw a different woman every night and spend all their money on video games and sports cars.
Yeah, it's silly (and embarrassingly heteronormative) but it's what I grew up assuming. All of the men in my life, my dad, grandfather, non crazy uncles, friends' fathers... Andy, too ... they totally fit the "clueless bumbling dad" stereotype. Can't figure out the washing machine, eat takeout every night if left to their own devices. When my mom died, my friends' moms started taking me grocery shopping every week and making sure I cooked and kept house for my dad. God forbid a man have to dust, lol. Then of course my dad got remarried like ten minutes after I left for college, reinforcing the "needs a woman to take care of him" thing.
But I can't offer that to Castle. I don't want to split my time between two husbands. I don't have the time or energy to be full blown wife to two guys without losing my mind. Between work, Andy, friends, dogs, house/errands stuff, exercise, and sleep, I can find a couple of days a week for him. That doesn't seem like '*enough* to warrant him seeing me exclusively here in Texas.
And I want that - to be his only girlfriend here. I can't help it. I just do. I dunno if it's NRE, or just that when sex with someone is great, I stop wanting anyone else. So un-poly of me. I mean, I'm not a stickler for monogamy. It doesn't bother me that he has sex with his wife when he's home. Even the occasional "this hook up opportunity popped up, why not" is cool. But the idea of him (anyone) going out and actively pursuing sex with others, it makes me feel inadequate. Me projecting my own shit, I guess. I had no interest in sex outside my marriage until the piv stopped. Even with Dag, I didn't want anyone but him, until he started treating me like crap, and then I was all about looking for new partners.
So that's where my brain gets stuck. I want this almost-sorta-monogamy thing, because that's what feels right and good to me. But I worry I'm not offering enough - enough time, enough sex, enough commitment - to deserve it.
For now though I'm trying to just ENJOY getting to have my cake and eat it too. Castle has offered up all this without me having to ask, and he seems thrilled with where we are, so I'm taking yes for an answer
