Cont...
CTF:
My real issue is twofold; The decision has already been made, so suggesting that I think long & hard about it is only useful if I could time-travel, and that you kinda
are arguing in favor of dis-honesty by way of advocating that anyone should keep something big to themselves (Even if the purpose is to keep from hurting them).
She hasn't said no per se, and her agreement to take time to think about it shows she is probably giving it some consideration. But I've said I'm willing to accept whatever decision she makes.
Never have I ever said anything close to "If she doesn't accept me this way then that's on her".
Yeah, it's this sort of extreme word choices that, while they may be 100% accurate, are why you come across as negative. If you truely are "dead inside" then it isn't simply a matter of "coming across" as negative, the issue is that you actually
are negative. No one who really feels that way is capable of communicating without their own situation influencing how they view the world, and how they treat others. I've felt dead inside plenty of times, and I've seen firsthand the difference between that version of myself and the "normal" me; No one wants to be around the negativity of someone who is dead inside.
The only thing that is clear at this point is that she currently is not excited by the idea, and is having trouble processing what it all means. Beyond that, speaking in absolutes is pointless and presumptive.
Again, she has not declined, as we have not had that discussion fully. She needs time to process the facts about how I view love & relationships. I do not have the answers yet.
As I said, I was not exposed to the idea of polyamory until like 10+ years into our relationship, so I was operating under the ideals I had been raised with, which told me that how I was feeling was "wrong". If ya wanna talk about pointless honesty why would I tell her "Yeah, so I love like, 3 people other than you... but I know it's wrong of me to feel that way, just felt like letting you know"
My initial post was hastily written, as I was writing it after an all-night cry-a-thon that left me with no idea what to do. But that's why I keep coming back and replying to specific things, to clarify on my original post. "Understanding" is a constantly shifting ideal, you have to stay open to new information and allow it to change your understandings.
I could almost agree with this, but there have been comments (not just from the monos) that talk about how hard it is for her to deal with this new information and the feelings it brings up. Several people have mentioned the suffering of their s/o when they dropped the bomb. I think it's clear that your s/o did not handle things properly, and a disaster was the result. But I'm obviously more interested in learning what people in my position did right, and how it helped create a better result.
Ahem...
Post #17: "It also doesn't alleviate the poly partner from the responsibility of causing that pain."
Post #26: "the whole "if she gives me the freedom & makes me happy will benefit her because I'll admire her more" nonsense is a naive fantasy. It's also an extremely disrespectful & unloving way to behave towards her."
Post #29: "I keep hearing that mantra about "honesty" & knowing the "full me/you", yet these same people generally ignore who their partner is, and what they need by not learning to bear the burden themselves."
Post #29: "The ONLY thing accomplished here, was a devastated mono partner, and an end to a relationship likely imminent."
Post #32: "we're talking about a complete lack of respect for the mono partner"
Post #32: "it shows how little they truly value them."
Post #32: "Like I said before, this situation usually only shifts the burden of pain onto the other partner. Amd often, telling that partner ends up being justified as though they're acting courteous to them, when they're really just trying make themselves feel better."
Post #55: "However, knowing that your gf would not be on board, and hoping to try anyway, not only is a clear breakdown of communication on your end, but highly disrespectful & naive."
Post #62: "The feeling of rejection when a poly partner comes out... especially after being together for so long is an indescribable feeling of rejection."
I think you can see how these statements can be read as pointing out unfairness towards one's s/o. Just sayin'...
Aaaaand...
Post #10: "She's never going to understand how you can love another"
Post #26: "Let it go. Don't just put of the poly discussion for a month, put it off forever if you plan to stay with her."
Post #26: "She's NEVER going to reach compersion..."
Post #55: "so that renders the open relationship hopes DOA, leaving nothing left, but to clear your own conscience.
Post #58: "is that as clear as it is to everyone now, that she'll never be on board"
These are pretty absolute terms you use. Again, just sayin'...
And no, you haven't been blocked. If I get too sick of you to even argue I'll just skip over your posts