As a non-parent AND a medical professional, I was curious as to my response to your list.
Frankly every parent I know is just doing the best they know how with the tools in their toolbox.
Frankly, NOT every parent I know is doing anything even close to "their best". Really. Should I have to tell people that putting Mountain Dew or Sweet Tea in a baby bottle is a BAD IDEA? No. But they do because "they like it". The parents that relate that their 18 month old will "only eat" McD's french fries and McNuggets...(when the parents themselves haven't eaten a vegetable in years because they are "gross")
-Childbirth planning choices
Mixed feelings on this. I think it is fine and good to think about options and have preferences. BUT, realize that circumstances change quickly. The NUMBER ONE goal is a healthy/live mom with a healthy/live baby. A mother is not a "failure" because the "birth plan" went awry!
This is a personal choice with heavy cultural overtones. All things being equal I would decide AGAINST - an unnecessary cosmetic procedure that carries the risk of complication and decreases glans sensitivity. But I don't have a penis and maybe "looking like everyone else" matters more to others (in which case I should have gotten breast implants at puberty!)
YES! This seems like a "no-brainer" to me. BUT, some women have such negative reactions that it inhibits their bonding with their baby - which is WAY worse than the minimal deficits of formula-feeding. Actually, I have a LOT of respect for women who recognize this and choose to pump and bottlefeed as an alternative.
SO subjective. I got spanked a LOT as a kid. I don't think it did me any harm and I was stubborn enough that a lesser punishment would have had little effect. BUT, I feel, I never got spanked out of frustration or anger. I never got spanked after I was old enough to know better.
My sisters got spanked a LOT less than I did. The middlest sister was good - she never really needed spanking. The littlest sister could have don't with a bit more...but it was the 80s and mom felt guilty by then (she NEVER, ever saved punishment until "your father gets home").
So, like jail, I think that "spanking" has it's time and place. Run into the street and risk getting hit by a car? A swat on your ass hard enough to remind you that that was the LESSER punishment for that stupid-ass thoughlessnesss = fair enough. Beating your kid to a pulp because they asked an honest question = abuse.
-Screen time & other entertainment
The AAP (American Academy of Pediatrics) recommends no more than 2 hours of "screen time" per day. (and also recommends at least 60 minutes of "activity" per day). I think it is the ratio that is important. During the school year - this seems reasonable. But in the summer? If you play outside for 10 hours, then watching a movie for 2 hours and surfing the internet for another 2 doesn't seem out of the range of healthy. Using videos, video games, etc. as a
de facto babysitter so you don't have to interact with your kid...lame.
-Pick up baby versus let them cry
So, I can see both sides here, and think that they both have their benefits (if I were a parent I think that I would be in the "let them cry" camp). One of the things that I love in my family is that we all respect the parents' choices on this one. I have one sister in the "pick them up" camp and one in the "let them cry" camp (even though she can't STAND to hear other peoples' babies cry and wants to cuddle them). My mother, a "let them cry" type TOTALLY abides by the parents' preference when she has the kids in her care.
So this also points to another point - unconditional love. All of the kids know, AT ALL TIMES, that the adults have their best interests at heart. Always. They may not understand it - but their parents would never let anyone who didn't place their safety first take care of them. The rules may be different at different houses - kids adapt, they can deal with this.
-Co-sleeping versus crib sleeping
This is one that I wish I felt differently about. BUT co-sleeping is a warm/fuzzy concept that kills babies. Not all. Not most. But some. And SOME is TOO MANY. And no, I DON'T trust the exhausted, sleep-deprived new parent to notice in their deep-sleep that they are smothering their kid. Because I have seen that fail. And ONCE is too many times.
My personal preference? A bed-height bassinet nudged up to the bed-edge. You can sleep touching your baby, you can put the side down and nurse on demand, and NOT smother your baby in your sleep.
Really? this is still a question. Here, I'll simplify it - breastmilk or formula for 4-6 months. Then introduce other foods gradually until 12 months. If you are a vegetarian make sure that your kids is getting adequate nutrients, especially vitamin B12. And no, for whatever organic non-breastfeeders are out there: raw goat milk + carrot juice is NOT FUCKING the SAME as breastmilk!
Really? Don't care, at all, except for sexuallizing pre-pubertal females - which is WRONG.
Bad. Actually, this is one of the reasons why I am glad that I am not a parent. What if my kid was bully? (I am smart and uninhibited and REALLY good at making cutting and biting comments when appropriate - maybe a bit of Napoleon complex at play as a I am a small, cute, female - what if a kid of mine used that skill to be a dick?)
Tell the truth. All of it it. Without judgement. I don't think that you can. So they need info from many different sources.
Yes. Just yes. And if you disagree with me, feel free to PM me and you better have FUCKING SCIENCE to back you up. A lot! Because I think that vaccines are the best thing that has ever happened in the history of science EVER. Better than transplant science. Better than antibiotics. Almost as good as WASHING your fucking HANDS!
Don't care. At all. What about homeschooling?
-College planning (or not)
I'm a bit of a Nazi about this and our sibs know it. My youngest Nephew was born in Novemeber and Sis had his 529 plan set up before Christmas - because that is important to me, even if no-one else contributes.
-Traditional nuclear family or nontraditional family, parental relationships, etc
and on and on and on...
And prepare to be CRUCIFIED. Because no matter how loving and dedicated you may be, someone thinks you're doing it completely wrong.
It's sad, you know, because you'd think that the joy of being a parent would bring us together and people would be more supportive.
Again. NOT a parent but the only thing on this list that gives me a rise (other than the Mountain Dew in the baby bottle thing that I mentioned) is really the anti-vaxxer stance.