I feel like I'm being put in the wrong box and would appreciate other's perspectives

shy guy

Member
My wife and I lead very busy lives apart, so we've agreed over the years to allow each other the freedom to talk to other people. It helps us get through the day and the stimulation leads to deeper intimacy between us when we are together. It's had its ups and downs, but overall has been a positive decision in our lives.

For my wife, this mostly manifests itself in a form of building sexual tension, edging, etc. She has a large online presence so there is no shortage of attractive guys knocking in her DMs at any given moment.

For me, it's been much more about finding someone to conversate with and feel a connection to, because I spend the majority of day alone (aside from animals). And I miss my connections and conversations I used to have when I was working full time.

My perspective is, put simply, that my wife has small relationships with many people and I want to have a big relationship with only one other person.

In all honesty, I struggle understanding what it is she gets out of what she does. It feels empty and shallow to me, but on her end it's fun and lite and just a distraction. So no matter how uncomfortable I've been with some of her actions, real or perceived (I make mistakes too), I've tried to support her and encourage her in every way I know how, because I feel that's what she needs from me. That's how I'm most supportive. And truthfully, that that is what she deserves. She's an amazing wife and we have a great life together when, well, we are together. We just spend soooo much time separate and in stressful situations. But we have a great marriage so I want to give her these things. She deserves my support and effort.

On my end, it seems she feels threatened by me having an emotional connection with this person and would rather I just sleep around. She's said as much. This is difficult for me, because while it sounds fun, I've experienced the depression I feel after an emotionless romp. I feel worse, not better. Sure, sexual tension is temporarily gone, but it's not satisfying to me. I don't feel fulfilled. So whenever she says anything along these lines I become guarded, but still do my best to offer what perverted sexually buried interest I'm able. I've been clear and she knows that just isn't my comfort zone. And at my age, I'm not sure that will change. I'm open to it, but not until I'm in a healthy place mentally, and that starts with wanting that, and I don't.

I have been talking to this lady online since April. A couple months ago, I opened the door so my wife and she could begin to communicate directly. Felt right at the time, and initially it was. The lady I've been talking with is a lot like me, very reserved and emotional. We have had great conversation and I feel like she could be a long-term important person to me. But also like me, she's afraid of letting others down, being a disappointment, etc. My wife seems to feel she's being dishonest and that she wants to be in a relationship with just me. I am positive that is not the case, but my wife sees it differently.

I feel my wife often tries to force me into her way of thinking or perspective. She talks about emotions in the same way that I would talk about sex and vice versa. I feel I often take a step to the side with my feelings, because I would honestly like to be someone who could sleep around for the fun of it. But the reality is, I don't actually want that. But at the same time, I don't want to limit her. What I do want is to have a lasting relationship with someone who treats me well and is kind and complimentary.

Something relevant to this for me is that my wife began her edging with strangers within our relationship without telling me. It was a spot of contention for awhile once I found out. Once I had someone of my own to put some focus into, I stopped worrying so much what she was doing and with who, because I felt by allowing me to have this one person, she was meeting me in the middle. So I've been able to embrace her more, due to having my own support or place to receive positive energy from, the past 6 months or so.

But now it feels like she's putting my other relationship into a box, as well, and is struggling with her intentions because of it. Trying to settle the feelings has pushed all of this into a non-enjoyable space and I've essentially now lost the positive from all of this. But she still gets to take her vibrator to work type of thing. Nothing has to change for her, but has at the same time put her insecurities onto the shoulders of this other lady that I've never even met, just talked to online. But because I opened that door for them to communicate, it's fallen on me to somehow mediate, as well. And now I'm feeling EXTREMELY guilty because this lady feels she's being treated like a homewrecker, but she's been nothing but respectful from day one. My wife has expressed that she doesn't trust it. I've definitely taken too much on here, but it feels dire at times in my wife's reactions. My wife feels that this lady should be able to have some type of communication open between them, and since they aren't friendly yet, it's because she wants more from me.

Now the lady I've been talking with since April feels like she's affecting a marriage that she saw as positive when she entered, now questionable. I'm taking on so much of the blame and so is this lady. My wife, however, while clearly having her own feelings, seems to be convinced that this person is trying to squeeze in, and I just don't think that's the case. At all. Not even a little. I'm not in love. I'm not falling for this lady, I'm just fostering a positive friendship that has gone no further than having genuine conversation on either side, so I'm confident my judgement isn't clouded with those types of emotions. When I think of loss with her it looks like a book I found enjoyable never being talked about, not some heart-wrenching pain. But it still sucks, still seems so very pointless.

I know life isn't fair and I know polyamory is different on either side, so I understand that fairness is not something I should be focused on, but I can think of no other way to say it than this feels unfair.

Does anyone have any perspective here that might help me in addressing this? I'm close to cutting ties with this lady, but I know resentment will swell if I do.

Thank you for your time.
 
My wife and I lead very busy lives apart, so we've agreed over the years to allow each other the freedom to talk to other people.

You kind of sound like you both date and share sex with other people but don't actually communicate that in your post in the most direct way. Is that just here in the post, or is that your usual communication style, kinda of indirect and passive?

It also sounds like you participate in group sex with your wife when you really don't want to share group sex. You just do it to please her, and it's getting old and kinda taxing on your mental health. Is that true?

What is "busy lives apart?" Are you in a long-distance marriage of some kind? Work different shifts? Something else?

What I do want is to have a lasting relationship with someone who treats me well and is kind and complimentary.

Do you have that with your wife, or not so much? Are you and wife actually compatible, or have you grown apart or gone in different directions?

Is this a healthy relationship? Before involving other people, you might have to assess THIS relationship first.




My perspective is, put simply, that my wife has small relationships with many people and I want to have a big relationship with only one other person.

Ok, you each have your own style. You seem to want friendship and perhaps actual polyamory. Wife wants non-monogamy or ENM. She's open for casual sex and that's it. She also seems to want group sex, but you aren't into that and have been doing it just to please her.

Is there some reason Wife can't share group sex with other people who are actually into that? And you pass because you are not into that?

On my end, it seems she feels threatened by me having an emotional connection with this person and would rather I just sleep around. She's said as much.

Ok, she told you how she's feeling. But she doesn't get to tell you how to date on your side, any more than you get to tell her how to date on her side.

This is difficult for me, because while it sounds fun, I've experienced the depression I feel after an emotionless romp. I feel worse, not better.

So don't do that kind of romping any more then. Date how YOU want to date. Be how YOU want to be. Stop bending yourself into pretzels to please Wife, or to enable her to skip working on her insecurities.

My wife seems to feel she's being dishonest and that she wants to be in a relationship with just me.

Well... what's wrong with that? What is wrong with this lady dating just you, and NOT being involved with your wife at all? There's nothing wrong with parallel poly.

Is there something wrong with you and Wife having a "mixed marriage," where she dates people for casual sex on her side, and you date people for lasting relationships on your side?

Because I opened that door for them to communicate, it's fallen on me to mediate.

This is where you get to tell this lady that you would like to online date her, but she's not required to have a relationship with your wife. Or you drop this lady and start over. Either way, this is where you get to tell Wife NO. No more "group" things. She dates on her side and you date on your side. You do not date the same people "together." You date separately.

I'm close to cutting ties with this lady but I know resentment will swell if I do.

Why would you be resentful of your wife when you've been the one accommodating or enabling her unreasonable and irrational requests, rather than telling her, "No, thanks. I won't be doing that," from the start?

If you don't want to break up with Lady, don't. If you do, do.

Either way, set personal boundaries with your wife and go parallel. Take personal responsibility for your choices. Stop floating along into stuff or people pleasing. Be your own authentic self.

That would be my suggestion to you.

Galagirl
 
Last edited:
Thank you so much for the thoughtful and thorough response. Much of this makes sense, especially us not being on the same page as far as types of ENM. You are correct, I am more polyamorous in how I feel and she is probably closer to monogamish. That's a good perspective, thank you. And no, neither of us are currently having sex with anyone else, just online play at this point, nothing that is that serious at all. And no, this lady isn't anything more than a friend. I did a poor job explaining, but you made your points and I will take something from this because of it.
 
Glad it helps you some.

Thank you for more info.

And no, neither of us are currently having sex with anyone else, just online play at this point, nothing that is that serious at all.

Do you and wife agree on what counts as "serious?"

And no, this lady isn't anything more than a friend.

Why is wife getting THIS bent out of shape over you having a friend? What's that all about?

Do you have other friends? Or not really?

Do ALL your friends also have to be friends with your wife? Or do you have your friends, she has her friends, and some are mutual friends?

Galagirl
 
You are both wired differently. There is no one way that's better than another way.

Your wife sounds like she's scared that if you have strong feelings for this other woman you may have less for her. You can assure her that love is not measured and will not run out. It may cause you to love your wife even more for having her blessing on this connection.

I enjoy flirty online relationships just like your wife does, but I won't be intimate with others unless there is a strong emotional bond. I do enjoy the attention of the online relationships. I enjoy the confidence-building, as I am 50 and it's nice to have men tell me I'm beautiful.

I have compassion for this other woman. She does not want to cause trouble between you and your wife. If your wife were to disapprove of this relationship it would be very very unfair to this woman. It would hurt her. And it might make you resentful.

I would suggest sitting down with your wife and offering reassurances of your love. But also suggest perhaps parallel poly, which means your wife and the woman will never talk or meet, unless they want to on their own terms. You will be the hinge and manage both relationships separately. It may be that this will make your wife feel more secure, as she will not see or hear about the other woman. If possible, see if you can find a poly-friendly counselor.
 
Do you and wife agree on what counts as "serious?"

I thought so, but I'm thinking we certainly got off track somewhere in the past couple of months. Our therapist sent us some worksheets we are going to start working on today, about setting healthy boundaries. So I'm hoping that helps us both navigate this.

Why is Wife getting THIS bent out of shape over you having a friend? What's that all about?

I think she felt threatened by her age, mostly. The lady is in her late twenties and that's come up a few times. I do think a good portion of this is tied to one or more insecurities, on my side included. I have issues I'm working through, as well, but mine are more about me, and hers are more about me. 😆 🤣 😂

Do you have other friends? Or not really?

Not many. I have a couple buddies I can shoot the shit with, but nothing too complex, certainly not emotional. And I have a few people I talk to on occasion from my old career, a couple texts a year.

Do ALL your friends also have to be friends with your wife? Or do you have your friends, wife has her friends, and some are mutual friends?

No, she has said that for anything to happen between us physically, they'd have to be friends. The problem for me was that was never where I saw this headed. When she said that, amongst other things, I wasn't sure how to proceed. I tried navigating it, but did a poor job. She feels if I only wanted a friendship, that I wouldn't even mention anything to my wife about her, because there would be no need. My perspective was that this person is giving me emotional support, so I should be forthcoming with my wife about it. That, so far, has been a poor choice on my part.

I think we need to take some steps back, get curious about one another's feelings, and try again.

I really do appreciate how blunt you are. This is exactly what I need. I beat around the bush a lot (to address one of your original questions) because I often feel like people are so intimidated by me in person, when I speak directly, I'm often met with defensiveness. My fear of that travels into my writing and obviously my marriage. It's something I'm working on, but clearly not there yet.
 
You are both wired differently. There is no one way that's better than another way.

Your wife sounds like she's scared that if you have strong feelings for this other woman you may have less for her. You can assure her that love is not measured and will not run out. It may cause you to love your wife even more for having her blessing on this connection.

I enjoy flirty online relationships just like your wife does, but I won't be intimate with others unless there is a strong emotional bond. I do enjoy the attention of the online relationships. I enjoy the confidence building, as I am 50, and it's nice to have men tell me I'm beautiful.

I have compassion for this other woman. She does not want to cause trouble between you and your wife. If she were to disapprove of this relationship it would be very very unfair to this woman, and would hurt her. And, it may make you resentful.

I would suggest sitting down with your wife and offering reassurances of your love. But also suggest perhaps parallel poly, which means your wife and the woman will never talk or meet, unless they want to on their own terms. You will be the hinge and manage both relationships separately. It may be that this will make your wife feel more secure, as she will not see or hear about the other woman. If possible, see if you can find a poly-friendly counselor.

This exactly. I strongly relate to everything here and think you are exactly right. We do have a poly-friendly therapist, We have made a lot of progress, but something here slid under the rug. I think a big part of it is my insecurity, since I wasn't looking for anything but talking with this person.

But because my wife doesn't want that same thing, she attempts to look at it through her lens. I give her so much benefit of the doubt that I didn't catch that that was what was happening, and I should've been cautious instead of trying to lead. Thank you for your response. I really appreciate the conversation.
 
This exactly. I strongly relate to everything here and think you are exactly right. We do have a poly friendly therapist, we have made a lot of progress but something here slid under the rug. I think a big part of it is my unsurity since I wasn't looking for anything but talking from this person.
But because my wife doesn't want that same thing, she attempts to look at it through her lens. I give her so much benefit of the doubt that I didn't catch that that was what was happening and I should've been cautious instead of trying to lead. Thank you for your response. I really appreciate the conversation.
My pleasure, and good luck!
 
It kind of sounds like wife wants open for herself, but not for you.

And kind of like she wants you to give her veto power over your other relationships. If she has to be friends with her meta before you date them or get physical? Most potentials won't like that you and wife are so joined at the hip like that. That takes care of them. Anyone willing to put up with it, your wife can decide not to be friends, and there, that solves the rest, because they have to be friends before you can date. She's got you coming and going.

She can CALL it open for both, but on your side it becomes de-facto closed.

You aren't into casual sex, but if you suddenly became so, I think your wife would find a way to object, for all that she says she's okay with it.

I think you could bring all that up in your next counseling appointment, or schedule an individual appointment with the therapist to talk about that without your wife there.

 Galagirl
 
Last edited:
It kind of sounds like wife wants open for her but not for you.

And kind of like she wants you to give her veto power over your other relationships. If she has to be friends with her meta before you date them or get physical? Most potentials won't like that you and wife are so joined at the hip like that. That takes care of them. Anyone willing to put up with it, your wife can decide not to be friends, and there, that solves the rest, because they have to be friends before you can date. She's got you coming and going.

She can CALL it open for both, but on your side it becomes de facto closed.

You aren't into casual sex, but if you suddenly became so, I think your wife would find a way to object, for all that she says she's okay with it.

I think you could bring all that up in your next counseling appointment, or schedule an individual appointment with the therapist to talk about that without wife there.

 Galagirl

Interestingly enough, I did just that this morning. I asked for a one-on-one to sort some of this out. I fear you're close to the mark, though. It's scaring me a little, if I'm being perfectly honest. I love my wife so much. It just feels like there's a massive disconnect between expectations and reality. I often feel like I'm in one of those "For me but not for thee" types of relationships. I continue to appreciate your responses. Thank you.
 
Interestingly enough, I did just that this morning. I asked for a one-on-one to sort some of this out. I fear you're close to the mark, though. It's scaring me a little, if I'm being perfectly honest. I love my wife so much. It just feels like there's a massive disconnect between expectations and reality. I often feel like I'm in one of those "For me but not for thee" types of relationships. I continue to appreciate your responses. Thank you.
"For me but not for thee": in polyspeak, we refer to these as "one-vagina policies," or "one-penis policies," OVP or OPP.
 
Hello shy guy,

Just out of curiosity, how long do you think you and your wife will continue to live very separate (and stressful) lives from each other? That seems to be a significant problem for you, in addition to any other concerns you may have.

From what I read in the book "Sex at Dawn," there is a tendency for husbands to feel more threatened when their wives have sex with other men, and a tendency for wives to feel more threatened when their husbands have emotional connections with other women. If this is true, then you and your wife have exactly the kind of dynamic that would stress each other out the most. I'm not saying this is something you should fix, just maybe that there are some grounds for the two of you to sympathize with each other.

I do not feel that you need to change. You want a lasting relationship with someone who treats you well and is kind and complimentary. That desire is a fundamental part of who you are. You do not want casual sex. That, too, is a fundamental part of who you are. Your wife is trying to get you to change, and I believe that is a mistake on her part. Just as you don't try to make her stop wanting casual sex (or edging), she should not try to make you stop wanting an emotional connection.

It seems to me that your wife wants you to cut your ties with the lady you've been conversing with since April. It seems doubtful that you could convince your wife to change her stance on this point, I don't know how you could convince her. In the meantime, she's doing all she can to undermine your relationship and good feelings with this since-April lady. I think her intention is to make you and the since-April lady so miserable in your once-happy relationship with each other, that you and the lady would be relieved to be done with each other. And at that point, your wife's objective would be met. I don't know how this can be fixed. It doesn't sound like your wife is going to stop trying to undermine your relationship with the lady.

Essentially what your wife wants is to continue to have the kind of interactions she wants, while you cease to have the kind of interactions you want. As I don't see her changing her mind about this, what you are left with is the unhappy task of deciding whether you're willing to stay married to your wife under those unfair conditions. If you're willing to stay, then you'll have to make the best of it.

Sympathetically,
Kevin T.
 
Hello shy guy,

Just out of curiosity, how long do you think you and your wife will continue to live very separate (and stressful) lives from each other? That seems to be a significant problem for you, in addition to any other concerns you may have.

From what I read in the book "Sex at Dawn," there is a tendency for husbands to feel more threatened when their wives have sex with other men, and a tendency for wives to feel more threatened when their husbands have emotional connections with other women. If this is true, then you and your wife have exactly the kind of dynamic that would stress each other out the most. I'm not saying this is something you should fix, just maybe that there are some grounds for the two of you to sympathize with each other.

I do not feel that you need to change. You want a lasting relationship with someone who treats you well and is kind and complimentary. That desire is a fundamental part of who you are. You do not want casual sex. That, too, is a fundamental part of who you are. Your wife is trying to get you to change, and I believe that is a mistake on her part. Just as you don't try to make her stop wanting casual sex (or edging), she should not try to make you stop wanting an emotional connection.

It seems to me that your wife wants you to cut your ties with the lady you've been conversing with since April. It seems doubtful that you could convince your wife to change her stance on this point, I don't know how you could convince her. In the meantime, she's doing all she can to undermine your relationship and good feelings with this since-April lady. I think her intention is to make you and the since-April lady so miserable in your once-happy relationship with each other, that you and the lady would be relieved to be done with each other. And at that point, your wife's objective would be met. I don't know how this can be fixed. It doesn't sound like your wife is going to stop trying to undermine your relationship with the lady.

Essentially what your wife wants is to continue to have the kind of interactions she wants, while you cease to have the kind of interactions you want. As I don't see her changing her mind about this, what you are left with is the unhappy task of deciding whether you're willing to stay married to your wife under those unfair conditions. If you're willing to stay, then you'll have to make the best of it.

Sympathetically,
Kevin T.

Thank you for the perspective, Kevin, it's valued. I think I poorly wrote the beginning. We see each other every night. We live in the same place, but she commutes two hours each way to the city. I am developing our land and taking care of the rescues, livestock, etc.

I very much think you are correct in the dynamic you specified from the book. That feels right and makes logical sense.

I'm not leaving my wife. We have a great relationship outside of this situation and work very well together, complimentary in other ways that far outweigh me needing a friendship. Having said that, I'm not laying down and letting it happen. I've been actively pushing back and I will until I, at the very least, feel heard. We are in therapy, have been for awhile and we are learning new ways of communicating all the time. I do understand the odds are stacked against us solving this straightaway. But I do think, in time, we'll overcome it. I am hearing you, though, and these responses have definitely made me look closer at that aspect. I feel she's trying, but I can see how this is going to be a long road. Thank you again.
 
Just to offer an interpretation of how your wife might be feeling:

For her, sexual relationships or sexual flirting interactions are easy and fun and do not need to have strong emotions involved. Emotional relationships are harder and more complex for her to find and develop, and she is happy having only one romantic emotional relationship (you). Her online sexual banter offers her the sexual variety she craves without having to have actual in-person sex (or emotional involvement) with anyone else, and it allows her to build up her arousal all day long and then bring all that sexual tension home to you.

Because emotional connections are so rare (and so rarely needed) for her, she is struggling with your online emotional friendship because she imagines it is a threat to her relationship with you.

You, meanwhile, view her online interactions as empty and shallow, which I don't think is fair to her (although I understand why you think that). It would be empty and shallow if she were seeking emotional connections online, but she's not. She's seeking sexual fulfilment for herself (and by extension, for you in your relationship with her, in that you get to experience the ultimate benefits of her sexual tension). To me, online sex seems like a safe and relatively harmless way for her to experience sexual variety and thrills. The men she chats with are probably seeking the same thing she is, online sex without deep emotional involvement, so she isn't hurting anyone or being irresponsible.

You recognize that you aren't interested in casual sex/online sex, so what you'd like for yourself is a meaningful online friendship. That's certainly not too much to ask, and you are right to stand firm that you won't give up your friendship. Your wife should not be involved in it and should not have to interact with your online friend, anymore than you need to chat with her DM dudes.

But definitely reassure her that your need for emotional friendship is not be a threat to her, anymore than her online chats are a threat to you. You just have greater emotional needs than she does, just like she has greater sexual needs than you do.
 
We see each other every night.
Since you've got two women here, can we please give them nicknames for ease of understanding? I'd call your friend April, and your wife May. You can use other names if you'd like, of course.
We live in the same place, but she commutes two hours each way to the city. I am developing our land and taking care of the rescues, livestock, etc. I very much think you are correct in the dynamic you specified from the book. That feels right and makes logical sense. I'm not leaving my wife. We have a great relationship outside of this situation and work very well together, complimentary in other ways that far outweigh me needing a friendship.
Do you think that just because you get along with May, it means you shouldn't need a friend?? Good grief. We all need friends, no matter how well-matched we may be with a partner or spouse. Do you actually think you shouldn't need a friend just because your marriage is kinda okay?

You absolutely should have all the friends you want. And I'd add in, friends you can chat with online, since you're home alone on a ranch with just animals for company most of the time, are even more important. May is gone to work (I assume she works an 8 hour day) and has a 4 hour commute. That's at least 12 hours a day you're alone. Why shouldn't you get to have a friend? Is May so controlling that she thinks she should be the ONLY person in your life, even while she's off chatting with men for X hours a week, edging them and herself, masturbating, just for fun? And she's otherwise some kind of internet celebrity as well, you've implied. But you can't have one good friend?
I'm not laying down and letting it happen. I've been actively pushing back and I will until I at the very least feel heard. We are in therapy, have been for awhile and we are learning new ways of communicating all the time. I do understand the odds are stacked against us solving this straightaway. But I do think, in time, we'll overcome it. I can see how this is going to be a long road.
Just a note for understanding. You may have made a common spelling mistake that confused me. You said you wanted a "complimentary" partner or relationship. I thought you mean someone who gave you compliments, praise, approval, that sort of thing. But now I am thinking you meant "complementary": combining in such a way as to enhance or emphasize the qualities of another or each other.

And above, about having every right to have friends, since you're in an ethically non-monogamous relationship, you should also be able to have sex partners/lovers if you desire.

By the way, is your wife edging with men while she's at work? Or when she's home, in the house with you, but ignoring you?
 
I've just read your original post again and I have a question.

Why are you mediating when they have a direct line of contact with each other?

My wife feels that this lady should be able to have some type of communication open between them, and since they aren't friendly yet, it's because she wants more from me.

Could you explain this a little more please? Who's the last "she" in this paragraph?
 
On the idea that she has a "for me, not for thee" attitude, I think we have to be realistic and honest about the differences in what you want.

As you said, you want one big relationship. You've chosen someone in their 20s to do so. People in their 20s are at a life stage where they are either deciding what type of lifestyle they want as an older adult, or they are actively working on it. Things like marriage and kids. Moving to where they want to be, things like that.

That's a totally different kettle of fish to having a casual sexual encounter with someone. If one if her guys move away, the chances that they'll need to work out a schedule for visitation is minimal. Whereas you want to actually build a life with someone else.

So she isn't actually saying "For me, but not for thee," she's saying, "That kind of thing shouldn't be for either of us, but what I'm doing is low enough risk for it to be okay for both of us. So do what I do."


You might want/need more than what she does, but you have to understand that it is very much further away from the relationship you've built.

That's a huge thing. The potential for disruption to your home life is much bigger. You are risking a lot of the stability you've built up by doing this. Inviting full actual relationships into your life is much different from casual sex with others.
 
This is really somewhat confusing. You are talking on a polyamory forum about having a mere friend? Or does this friendship contain erotica? Is there a plan to take it physical? I still don't understand your declared intent on that.

I think your need for more emotional depth, friendship and intimacy is very valid. Anyone would be lonely being alone for 12 hours a day with no close friendships. You definitely need people around.

It also sounds, from what you wrote about your wife, that you are lacking emotionality even with your wife. The marriage is good, but doesn't quite meet your need for depth.

Considering all of the above, I also think your wife is correct to be concerned. The probability that you'll fall in love with this April lady who is currently your main source of emotional connection and support is very, very high. Can you see that? Not everyone can have a bestie of the opposite sex, especially if they come at a time of increased loneliness/vulnerability, especially if non-monogamy isn't completely off the table.

You "catching feelings" and acting on them would take your relationship full-on poly, with all the complications it brings. I don't think you and your wife have talked through that possibility thoroughly enough.

If you want to keep April as your friend, and not risk shaking your marriage's values to their roots, I think you must 1) take on a monogamous mindset with her and commit to keeping it strictly platonic, no sex talk, no flirting or fantasies, 2) find more friends, so that she's not the only one standing out as THE person you can talk to.

You should move in direction of point #2 in every case.

Good luck 🤠
 
Last edited:
Back
Top